Managing Glyphosate- and ALS-Resistant Kochia in the Panhandle

Managing Glyphosate- and ALS-Resistant Kochia in the Panhandle December 15, 2016

glyphosate-resistant kochia in a greenhouse trial
Figure 1. The maximum labeled glyphosate rate was applied to this kochia plant in a UNL trial. While it suffered some chlorosis, it recovered and continued growth.

Learn more at Crop Production Clinics this January

Nevin Lawrence will be discussing this topic in more detail at the Nebraska Extension Crop Production Clinic in Gering Jan. 4. This is the first of nine Crop Production Clinics scheduled across Nebraska.

Management of herbicide-resistant weeds is a common theme at this year's Crop Production Clinics. Learn more about the clinics and the new Nebraska Crop Management Conference and register today to get the latest research updates and recommendations for Nebraska.

Kochia has been a problem weed in the Panhandle for decades. Before the arrival of RoundUp® Ready crops, kochia (kochia scoparia) became resistant to the triazine class of herbicides (group 5) as atrazine was commonly used in both corn and dryland fallow rotations. Following the development of sulfonylurea chemistries, kochia quickly became resistant to the ALS-inhibiting herbicides (group 2) as well. In 2011 glyphosate-resistant kochia was confirmed in Nebraska for first time.

In hindsight, the arrival of glyphosate-resistant kochia populations in Nebraska should not have come as a surprise. Glyphosate (group 9) is used in virtually every crop in the Panhandle, as a burndown treatment before planting, as a POST-applied herbicide in RoundUp Ready® crops, or to control weeds in fallow systems. Depending on the crop rotation, a particular field can easily see two to three applications of glyphosate every year, often without any other herbicide being used in the system. As the use of atrazine has decreased, so has the incidence of triazine-resistant kochia. This is because triazine-resistant kochia produces less seed and grows more slowly than a “normal” kochia biotype. This isn’t the case with ALS or glyphosate resistance, which does not subside once it's present in a population.

Dryland Cropping Systems

Kochia can be outcompeted by a competitive winter wheat stand, and tends to be more prevalent in areas where the stand is thinner. Kochia will typically become noticeable in healthy wheat stands near harvest or soon after harvest when little crop competition remains. This period post-harvest, or during the fallow period where no crop is grown for a year, kochia can be more difficult to control. To complicate control in fallow, most herbicide programs rely on glyphosate applied multiple times a year to control weeds. As a burndown or in fallow, simply adding 2,4-D or dicamba as a tank mix partner with glyphosate is often not effective enough to achieve consistent control of glyphosate resistant-kochia especially when not used at higher rates. Using glyphosate tank mixtures with 2,4-D, dicamba, fluroxypyr containing products, or MCPA at sufficiently high rates with appropriate adjuvants per label instructions is the best method to obtain satisfactory chemical control.

Gone are the days when you could use partial or lower herbicide rates and still achieve good results. Timely applications when weeds are small and with appropriate adjuvants cannot be emphasized enough. Kochia growing in hot dry environments uses different biological methods to protect itself. Adjuvants help the herbicides to get through these barriers and into the plants. In some cases, tillage could be used to limit seed going back into the seed bank.

Irrigated Cropping Systems

Kochia is among the earliest emerging summer annual weeds, with germination starting in early March. However, the bulk of kochia emergence occurs in early April. What this means for corn and sugarbeet production is that a competitive population of kochia can be well established before planting. Early weed control is essential to prevent yield loss in both corn and sugarbeet. In corn, multiple herbicides are available that can provide control of glyphosate or ALS-resistant kochia both in conventional or limited-till production systems (Table 1).

In sugarbeet, PRE- or POST-emergent herbicides offer limited control of kochia. UpBeet can control populations not resistant to ALS-inhibiting herbicides, but most kochia populations in the Panhandle are now resistant to this mode of action. The best option in sugarbeet is adding Norton PRE, which does have activity on both glyphosate- and ALS-resistant kochia. However, Nortron only provides around 40%-60% control when applied at rates greater than 24 fl oz per acre.

With limited options to control herbicide-resistant kochia in sugarbeet, it becomes essential to use rotational strategies to prevent new seed from entering the soil seed bank. This is a particularly effective strategy for kochia as kochia seed is only viable for two to three years. Corn is a good choice for a rotational crop because many herbicide options are available to control herbicide-resistant kochia. Winter wheat or dry beans are also good options for rotation with sugarbeet. By the time dry beans are planted, most kochia will have emerged, making it possible to control it through tillage or non-selective herbicides before competition or seed production occurs. Winter wheat is likely the best rotation option.

Research trials conducted at the Panhandle Research and Extension Center in Scottsbluff  have demonstrated that wheat can completely suppress the emergence of kochia even when no herbicide was applied. If kochia does emerge within an irrigated wheat canopy, several herbicides are available to control kochia.

Table 1. Herbicide options for controlling glyphosate and ALS-resistant kochia
HerbicideTimingRate (per acre)
— Corn (will allow rotation to dry beans or sugarbeets) —
Valor + 2,4-D (4 lb) 14 DBPA 2 fl oz + 16 fl oz
VerdictB PRE 15 fl oz
Dicamba + 2,4-D POST 8 fl oz + 4 fl oz
Starane Ultra + 2,4-D POST 6.4 fl oz + 4 fl oz
— Irrigated or Dryland Small Grains and Fallow —
Huskie + 2,4-D (4 lb) POST 14 fl oz + 8 fl oz
Huskie + MCPA POST 14 fl oz + 12 fl oz
Widematch POST 1 pt
Curtail M POST 2 pts
Curtail POST 2 pts
Dicamba + 2,4-D POST 6 fl oz + 8 fl oz
AAbbreviations: DBP, Days Before Planting; PRE, pre-emergent herbicide; POST, post-emergent herbicide.
B Will require adding another herbicide to control emerged weeds.
*See the Nebraska Extension publication, 2017 Guide for Weed, Disease, and Insect Management in Nebraska (EC-130), and product labels for information on required adjuvants and additional use instructions.
Reference to commercial products or trade names is made with the understanding that no discrimination is intended and no endorsement by University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension is implied.