May 4, 2007

Correct White Grub Identification Key to Control in Field Crops

There are two major types of white grubs found in Nebraska field crops; the annual white grubs (Cyclocephala or masked chafer), and the three-year white grub (Phyllophaga spp.).

Annual white grubs are by far the most common type found in most crop fields and are the same type that injure turf later in the summer. At this time of year, annual white grubs are finishing up their larval period and preparing to pupate. They typically do relatively little feeding in the spring and rarely cause economic damage.

The three-year white grub is potentially much more damaging. Eggs are laid in one summer, hatch out, and the white grubs feed over the next three years. When present in large numbers, they can cause significant damage to seedling crops, particularly in the second and third summers of their life cycle.

Annual white grub larva (Cyclocephala) Three-year white grub larva (Phyllophaga) Figure 1. To distinguish the annual white grub (Cyclocephala) from the three-year white grub (Phyllophaga), look at the underside of the last abdominal segment of the white grub.  You will need a hand lens to see these features.  The annual white grub has a random scattering of spines, but the three-year grub has two parallel rows of spines. (Photos by Jim Kalisch)

The best way to identify which type of white grub is present is to look at the pattern of spines on the underside of the last abdominal segment (see Figure 1). Annual white grubs have numerous spines arranged randomly on the segment. The three-year white grub has spines arranged into two parallel rows. This can be easily seen with a 10X hand lens.

If three-year white grubs are found in densities exceeding one per square foot, a planting time insecticide should be considered (liquid, granular or seed treatment insecticide). There are no post-emergence insecticide applications effective as a rescue treatment if damage is seen as crops emerge.