University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension, Institute of Agriculture and Natural Resources

November 21, 2006

No-till leads yields in long-term tillage field comparison

In order to gain management experience and production data, a long-term tillage system study was established in 1981 at the University of Nebraska Rogers Memorial Farm, 10 miles east of Lincoln. These research and demonstration plots, started as a dryland soybean/grain sorghum rotation common to southeast Nebraska at the time, are showing that long-term no-till builds soil structure, usually has the highest yield, and is the most profitable. This year, the soybeans were planted into corn residue as the one set of the plots was changed to a corn/soybean rotation in 2005. (See the 2005 yield report in the October 28, 2005 CropWatch.)

Table 1. 2006 grain yields for various tillage systems at the dryland Rogers Memorial Farm.
 
Yield, bu/ac
Tillage System
Soybeans
Grain Sorghum
Plow-disk-disk
43.2
92.1
Chisel-disk
55.7
90.2
Disk-disk
56.2
90.1
Disk
58.9
91.3
No-till w/cultivation
61.5
93.7
No-till
62.0
99.6
The soybean and grain sorghum yields from 2006 showed that no-till did quite well in a year with little rainfall early in the growing season. The season started with almost a full soil moisture profile from the 7.75 inches of precipitation that fell since the last harvest; however, an on-site weather station recorded only 3.4 inches of rain from May 1 to August 1, far below average. From August 1 until September 10, an additional 5.5 inches of rain fell, really helping the soybeans but coming a little late for the grain sorghum. As such, soybean yields were above average for the conservation tillage systems and grain sorghum yields were below the long-term averages for this study.

It was observed that the residue on the soil surface for the conservation tillage systems reduced evaporation and kept the soil cooler during the heat of the summer. Even row crop cultivation of the no-till reduced the yields, especially for the grain sorghum, as the soil surface was loosened and some residue was lost. However, it was interesting to note a "greening up" of the no-till soybeans immediately following cultivation, just as the old timers used to say about a crop responding to cultivation. Yet there was no yield increase to justify the cost of cultivation.

The continued use of no-till has improved soil structure and protects the soil surface with residue. With less crusting and reduced runoff, more soil moisture is available for the crop, resulting in higher yields.

Paul Jasa
Extension Engineer

You've got mail!
To receive Email notification when the latest Crop Watch is posted to the Web, use this form.

Copyright 2006 by the University of Nebraska Board of Regents. All rights reserved.
Published by University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension in the Institute of Agriculture and Natural Resources Cooperating with the counties and the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
The University of Nebraska-Lincoln does not discriminate on the basis of gender, age, disability, race, color, religion, marital status, veteran's status, national or ethnic origin, or sexual orientation.