|
April 26, 2002
Grain sorghum
Insects
Weed control
Climate -- Weather
Management
Updates
AgNews![]()
5-year corn/sorghum trials prove value of each
| |
In NU Cooperative Extension field trials in south central and southeast Nebraska since 1997, crop specialists compared the productivity of corn and sorghum side by side in dryland farmers' fields. They used management practices appropriate to each crop and area. Research found sorghum usually yielded better in fields expected to yield below 120 bushels per acre. However, if yields are expected to be above 140 bushels per acre, corn usually will yield more, said Steve Melvin, extension educator in Frontier County and formerly an extension educator in Nuckolls County, where some of the research was conducted. The yields in the 120 to 140 bushels per acre range would be similar for the two crops.
The 2001 results in south central Nebraska show when it is fairly dry during the corn grain-fill period and extremely dry later during the sorghum grain-fill period, corn will outyield sorghum, Melvin said. The previous years' data show the opposite is true with a little rain later in the summer.
These trials emphasize there are distinct advantages to having both corn and sorghum in the same year, said Roger Elmore, crops specialist at the South Central REC near Clay Center. "You don't know what kind of weather you'll have. Planting corn and sorghum spreads out the risk and provides excellent crop rotation benefits," he said.
IANR specialists have rotated field trials in Gage, Lancaster, Nuckolls, Otoe and Webster counties over the past five years.
The 2001 trials were in Webster and Lancaster counties. In Webster County, where it was extremely hot and dry during late summer, 18 corn hybrids were planted in the same field with 19 sorghum hybrids. Both crops were planted no-till into wheat stubble. Corn yields ranged from 108 to 160 bushels per acre with an average of 138 bushels per acre. Sorghum yields ranged from 108 to 148 bushels per acre with a 135-bushel per acre average.
In Lancaster County, which also was dry much of the summer, 60 corn hybrids and 35 sorghum hybrids were no-tilled into bean stubble. Corn yields averaged 129 bushels per acre and ranged from 104 to 171 bushels per acre. The sorghum plot had a poor stand and only 11 commercial hybrids were included in these comparisons. They averaged 115 bushels per acre and ranged from 95 to 131 bushels per acre.
The last five years of data from Nuckolls and Webster counties show sorghum yielding 126 bushels per acre and corn 112 bushels per acre, giving sorghum a 14 bushel per acre advantage over corn.
Three years of data from Gage, Lancaster and Otoe counties resulted in 139-bushel-per-acre corn yields and 130-bushel-per-acre sorghum yields, giving corn a nine-bushel-per-acre advantage at these higher yields.
The plots in south central Nebraska were planted no-till into wheat stubble each year except 1997 when the stubble was disked once. The southeast plots were planted no-till into soybean stubble two out of the three years. The excellent yields in these plot are directly related to the water saving practice of no-till farming, Melvin said.
"Another observation from these trials is that dryland corn hybrid selection is more critical than for grain sorghum," Melvin said. "The variation between the top and bottom yielding corn hybrid was 20 bushels per acre more then for the sorghum."
|
The market price also makes a difference. During the last couple of years, grain sorghum prices have been a few cents a bushel below and occasionally above corn prices, said Roger Selley, extension farm management specialist.
Traditionally the grain sorghum price is based on the feed value and sorghum is less valuable for a feed source. However, today other factors are influencing grain sorghum prices. For example, grain sorghum is a better base for dog food and more is being exported to Mexico, he said. "The price depends on what's happening in the market place now," he said. "There's been a shift, but the question is how long these conditions will prevail.
Sandi Alswager
Newswriter
IANR News and Publishing
The growing point for recently planted corn is near where the seed was planted. If there was
some soil moisture, especially from a recent rain, there should be little damage from the frost.
Recent tillage also can affect the potential for damage by creating a direct path from the cold air
down into the soil and seed cavity. At this point, however, even if the leaves have emerged and
are burned back, there should not be any permanent damage to the plants.
Spring grains such as oat and spring wheat are able to tolerate fairly low temperatures at their
current growth stage. Winter wheat will tolerate low temperatures as long as the growing point is
near ground level. The growing point will not be in danger until it gets close to the boot stage.
Even then it is quite well protected. It becomes very vulnerable after the head has emerged and
pollination is taking place. No place in Nebraska has reached that point.
Lenis NelsonFrost worries: When temperatures dip in late April, do crops do the same?
How low the temperature goes and how long it stays there are the first concerns for possible frost
injury to crops at this time of year. Other important factors to consider are the position of the
growing point and the soil moisture present.
Extension Crop Variety and Seed Production Specialist
|
According to growing degree accumulations, alfalfa weevil activity should have begun in most of the state by now. Weevil larvae usually begin causing noticeable damage at about 350 GDD (48 degree base).
Clover leaf weevils (CLW) are occasionally a problem in dry springs but are very vulnerable to a fungus disease, and so haven't been pests since the late 80s early 90s when spring rains were rare. Clover leaf weevil larvae will be in the debris around the crowns during day. Scratching in the soil around the crowns and counting the number of larvae found per crown will help give a better idea of clover leaf weevil infestation. Their brown heads will help distinguish them from the black headed alfalfa weevil. The chart below compares the alfalfa and clover leaf weevil. Both the alfalfa weevil and clover leaf weevil feed on first cutting alfalfa as larvae and regrowth of the first cutting as adults. While research conducted in northeast Nebraska has shown that clover leaf weevil larvae feeding does not cause yield reduction to first cutting alfalfa, alfalfa weevil feeding can cause severe losses to yield and quality of the first cutting.
Weevil management
Several methods can be used to reduce weevil populations. At this time of year, economic
infestations are usually dealt with by insecticide use or early harvest, depending on the alfalfa's
height. Other non-chemical control methods that have been used for alfalfa weevil management
include flaming, flooding, crushing of eggs and larvae, disking or harrowing, seeding dates, and
use of resistant varieties. The easiest way to begin weevil management is to select a resistant or
tolerant variety that will yield well in your area. The grazing of alfalfa in fall and winter is
becoming more popular and will reduce overwintering egg populations, particularly in southern
areas where a significant number of eggs, as well as adults, may overwinter.
In a recent Oklahoma study, cattle reduced the density of weevil eggs by over 60%. Grazed alfalfa may not be as attractive to egg-laying females in the spring although more research needs to be done to determine the factors involved. It is essential that fields be monitored for alfalfa weevil feeding now. Damage consists of small holes and interveinal feeding on the newest leaflets near the stem tips. The larvae are small (1/16 to 3/8 inch in length) and a pale yellowish green, which turns to a darker green when they are larger. These legless worms have black heads and a white stripe the length of the back. The alfalfa weevil larvae, which curl into a C-shape when disturbed, spend nearly all their time on the plant.
Once the alfalfa is about 4-6 inches high, take a bucket, carefully cut some stems at ground level (30 to 50 per field, from various spots in the field) and shake the stems against the side of the bucket. Average the number of weevil larvae per stem. Use these charts to help you determine whether control is necessary. Each chart has been developed for a specific alfalfa value. The decision as to whether to treat or re-sample depends on the average number of weevils per stem, the stem length, and the value of the alfalfa. When alfalfa reaches a certain height, it may be more profitable to cut the alfalfa early rather than treat. Insecticides registered to control alfalfa weevil larvae include Ambush, Baythroid, Cythion, Furadan, Guthion, Imidan, Lannate, Lorsban, Mustang, Penncap M, Pounce, Sevin, and Warrior. Visit the UNL Entomology Web site to check for use rates.
Keith Jarvi
IPM Extension Assistant
Northeast REC
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Total precipitation for April 16-21 generally ranged from 0.50 - 1.00 inch across the eastern half
of the state. Northeast Nebraska received the most generous amounts, with totals decreasing
considerably toward western Nebraska. The recent activity has provided some surface moisture
for planting, but has not reduced drought concerns.
The Nebraska Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS) reported dismal topsoil and subsoil levels
for most of the state as of April 21. The percent of fields reporting topsoil as short to very short
are: Panhandle (64%), north central (26%), northeast (42%), central (90%), east central (64%),
southwest (89%), south central (89%), and southeast (53%). Subsoil condition continues to
remain poor with the percentages of fields reporting short to very short conditions as follows:
panhandle (70%), north central (42%), northeast (43%), central (89%), east central (78%),
southwest (74%), south central (84%), and southeast (63%).
To add insult to injury, snowpack in the Colorado and Wyoming mountains which feeds the
Platte watershed was only 80% of what it was by the end of March last year. This represents
less than 60% of the historical average. Even after a heavy snow April 19-21, snowpack water
equivalents rose less than five percent. Streamflow projections for this summer are for less than
60% of normal flow if normal precipitation is received for the period.
It is anticipated that further reservoir draw downs will occur this summer for Enders, Harlan,
McConaughy, and Swanson. Irrigation delivery restrictions are a certainty for Enders and
Swanson users, with initial estimates placing deliveries at six inches for the season. No
restrictions are anticipated for McConaughy this year, but a below normal snowpack this winter
would likely force authorities to visit the issue next spring.
Weather outlooks do offer some rays of hope. Forecasts for the next week point to several
systems working across the state. Because of recent storm activity, there may be more moisture
at the surface to feed these systems and improve rainfall prospects. The large temperature
fluctuations experienced between each of the systems means that severe storm activity will likely
occur.
It is important that these systems deliver rainfall in a consistent manner. Rainfall deficits for the
year are running two to five inches across the state. This represents 30%-60% of normal
precipitation, depending on location. Areas that have been hardest hit and need to see
significant moisture are central and southwest Nebraska and the Nebraska Panhandle.
Precipitation outlooks for May do not give us any direction as there are equal chances of
receiving below normal, normal, or above normal precipitation across the entire state. However,
the 90-day outlook for the May - July indicates a tendency toward above normal precipitation for
the entire state, with the highest probabilities assigned to the eastern two-thirds of Nebraska.
It is extremely unusual for 90-day outlooks to indicate a wet bias across the central Plains during
the summer. Due to the nature of thunderstorm activity, models generally assign a climatology
ranking to summer precipitation forecasts, meaning equal chances of below normal, normal, or
above normal conditions. That is precisely what the forecasts are indicating for the June-August,
July-September, and August-October periods.
After analyzing the 90-day outlooks, it appears that the wet forecast for the May-July period
indicates that June is contributing to the above normal tendency of the three-month precipitation
forecast. However, it also indicates a bias toward drier than normal conditions in August. This
would be consistent with a building El Nino event forecast to reach full maturity by December.
The one thing researchers are not clear on is how El Nino events will contribute to precipitation
and temperature trends during the next 20 years. The Pacific Ocean has undergone a 20-year
circulation oscillation from a warm phase to a cold phase. Since model input for long-lead
outlooks favors the warm phase, there is some model uncertainty to whether the cool phase will
exhibit similar climatic influences around the globe during El Nino events. Time will tell.
Al DutcherForecasts offer hope of precipitation
Dry conditions continue to plague the state, even after several storms passed through. Severe
thunderstorms formed across central Nebraska and raced rapidly eastward dumping brief, heavy
rain, hail, and strong straight line winds April 16. In addition, there was a steady rain occurred
across eastern Nebraska April 20-21.
State Climatologist
|
The key to good control of musk thistle with herbicides is to control young plants in early May while they're in the rosette stage. Treatment after bolting is less effective because seeds may still develop. Uncontrolled plants can produce up to 20,000 seeds.
Although musk thistle is not poisonous, livestock will not graze near the plants and may refuse to enter heavily infested areas. Musk thistle is highly competitive with desirable forage species for sunlight, moisture and nutrients.
Cultural control
Good management in cultivated crops usually retards musk thistle. Fields with heavy infestations
could be cropped for a few years so tillage and herbicides could reduce infestations. Good
grazing management also will retard infestations in grazing land. Grasslands grazed too closely
are prime candidates for musk thistle infestation. Heavy livestock use opens forage stands to
musk thistle, especially in moist areas.
Mechanical control
Musk thistle can be suppressed by mowing or shredding, resulting in reduced seed production. In
most stands mowing at early bloom stage is best because plants will not resprout, although
younger plants may require additional control measures (Figure 1). Cutting plants at the base will
kill individual plants since they don't resprout from the roots. Seed may be produced by plants
cut in full bloom so heads should be removed.
Biological control
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Chemical control
Several herbicides offer good control of musk thistle (Table 1). Apply herbicides when plants are
in the rosette stage and prior to bolting. Control declines with herbicide application after the
rosette stage (Figure 1).
Grazing restrictions apply to the treatments described above so use caution. Lactating dairy animals should not graze for one week after a 2,4-D or Banvel application and two weeks after Curtail or Tordon. Hay harvest interval for lactating dairy animals for Banvel is 37 days, 2,4-D and Curtail is 30 days and Tordon is 14 days. Neither Ally nor Stinger have grazing or haying restrictions. Follow all precautions to prevent contamination of livestock and or hay.
Alex Martin
Extension Weeds Specialist
Option is a new postemergence herbicide in corn that has just been labeled. It is being
manufactured by Aventis and is a sulfonylurea herbicide with ALS mode of action. It's primary
spectrum of control is grassy weeds.
Brady Kappler
Don't treat the crop as a second rate, cheap alternative for use on the poorest cropland. Milo will
need 1.1 pounds of nitrogen per bushel of expected yield. The exact choice of nitrogen is not
important, but it is important that it be properly applied to avoid any losses. Phosphorus response
in grain sorghum is quite high, particularly on poorer fields. Most top producers are not satisfied
with low or medium phosphorus tests on owned land. They would like to move those soil test
levels to almost 20 ppm. Starter fertilizer provides for readily available nitrogen and phosphorus.
By helping the plants get off to a fast start it also will reduce weed competition. In addition, crop
rotation is a must for most producers.
Selecting top hybrids is vital. Most top producers rely on company representatives for
information, but they also often have a healthy tendency to conduct strip trials and review as
much data as possible from other trials. There is a mixed response to Gaucho use, unless the area
is near a wheat field. Wireworm seems like the greatest concern in stand establishment.
Greenbug protection is provided by scouting and treatment versus variety selection for resistance.
Top planter operation and proper depth control are a must to top production plans. Most, but not
all, top producers no-till grain sorghum into wheat stubble and soybean stubble. Most producers
are planting from 75,000 to 85,000 seeds per acre in southeast Nebraska and 50,000 to 70,000 in
south central Nebraska. Most producers like mid to mid late season hybrids and like to plant in
the first 20 days of May.
Weed control is essential and top producers are vigorous in keeping the field clean, especially for
annual grasses. Since grain sorghum has a more limited selection of herbicides than corn, it's
important to use what tools are available in the best way. Early preplant herbicide applications
limit weed development. Many producers will split applications or be vigorous in their use of
early post treatments to eliminate grass escapes.
The only answer to the government farm program issue is to be sure yields are reported for crop
insurance to get the protection level up. It will be a great help if sorghum and corn loan rates are
equalized.
Paul Hay, Extension Educator
New herbicides and label changes
Clearout 41 Plus is a isopropylamine salt of a glyphosate formulation being distributed by
Zetachem USA. At this time it is labeled for non-crop weed control and Roundup Ready
soybeans only.
Weed Science Educator
Top producer tips for high-yielding grain sorghum
Top grain sorghum producers shared tips for increasing yields at this year's grain sorghum
conferences. They have achieved success despite current barriers to sorghum production,
including yields and technological advances which have not increased at the same rate as corn
and a farm program which offers fewer protections. Their suggestions - grouped into areas of
influence - follow:
Gage County
Dryland yields suggest effects of rotations
From 1994 through 2001, I gathered yield, prior crop and tillage data on more than 1250 fields in
greater Gage County. As you can tell by the charts, some rotations have limited numbers of
fields. The table columns labeled "Conv. Till" and "No-till" indicate yield in bushels per acre.
While many factors such as fertilization, crop variety, field history, etc. are missing in this data
set, it does provide some insight into these production factors. The entire data set including some
irrigated fields is available on the Gage County Web site.Soybeans
| Crops | Stubble | No. Fields | Conv. Till | No. Fields | No-till | |
| Soybean | Corn | 40.0 | 113 | 39.9 | ||
| Soybean | Soybean | 37.8 | 17 | 37.8 | ||
| Soybean | Milo | 36.8 | 48 | 38.4 | ||
| Soybean | Wheat | 41.9 | 10 | 42.1 | ||